MLB–Going about the Right Thing in the Wrong Way

By 3 Permalink 2

 Hi all.  With some time before a handful of people watch the upcoming World Series, I wanted to fill you in on an idea which is now in the planning stages. If Major League Baseball (MLB) and Minor League Baseball (MILB) have their way, more than two score of small towns and cities won’t have minor league baseball as they know it, in some cases as they’ve known it for decades. 

  I haven’t been secretive about my opinion that a number of failing major league teams need to drop off the map.  I think Bud Selig had one good idea in his ill-spent reign as Commissioner, which was the idea to shut down the Expos and Twins entirely at the end of 2002.  Then he didn’t follow through.  Now, at the major league level, not only are we stuck with the 31 teams we have, (a lot of which are horrid) but MLB wants to expand.  The talent pool is desperately shallow now and could easily dry up entirely if any more MLB teams are born.   

  While I would have preferred some major league teams to fold their tents, I don’t like the proposal that 42 minor league teams now affiliated with MLB squads could be shut down after the 2020 season.  MLB and MILB have to reach an agreement by then, and this proposal will be contentious at best. 

    In these days of ridiculously expensive MLB tickets, ($15,000 per seat for game 1 of the upcoming World Series, SRO at $470.00,) the minor leagues have offered a quality product at usually reasonable prices.  I was blessed to be able to broadcast minor league baseball just as it began to boom.  This boom came about before, during and after the bitter MLB strike of 1994-95.  With the boom came higher attendance and the sound of cash registers jingling at gates and concession stands in minor league cities from Lethbridge, Alberta to Ft. Lauderdale.  The present proposal would cut the minor leagues down from 160 to 120 teams.  MLB is aware that some cities (Hagerstown, New Orleans, San Antonio) have stadiums that aren’t up to snuff. New Orleans has already lost their AAA team with their stadium being the reason.  The team at AAA Pawtucket, a Red Sox team since the 1970’s is moving after next season.  The reason is the same–it’s cheaper to build new than to upgrade McCoy Stadium in Pawtucket.  Those moves are on a case-by-case basis.  MLB is making noises about closing the Appalachian League and Pioneer League (Rookie ball) and the New York Penn League (short-season A-ball) entirely and reclassifying teams that continue to exist.  No change this dramatic has been proposed in more than 50 years.    

  Where teams remain, MLB hopes to work with MILB on raising salaries for minor leaguers, improving their travel and upgrading their accommodations on the road. MLB also wants minor league teams to stop changing affiliations every two or 4 years.  In a handful of seasons, Trenton, New Jersey went from being a Tiger team, to the Red Sox, then the Yankees as they are now.  They’ve stuck with the Yankees for nearly two decades, which is what MLB hopes to see happen more often.  They don’t want the Mets’ AAA team to be in Las Vegas, as it was until 2019 began and they moved to Syracuse.  For a while, the Marlins had a AAA team in Calgary.  You may only guess what happened if a major leaguer got hurt and a replacement was needed quickly. If you can’t guess, the answer is it took too long to get a guy from Calgary to almost anywhere in the majors. 

  If the present proposal is ratified, the Northwest League (now a short-season league) will expand to a full 140-game schedule. Meantime, 0 games will be played in places like Batavia, Staten Island and Brooklyn, (all in New York) Lowell, (Massachusetts) and Mahoning Valley, Ohio where the New York Penn league team has had entries since the time when I was a broadcaster. If the league shuts down, New Britain Stadium (home of the Connecticut Tigers) won’t have a team connected to the bigs. Most of the 10 Appalachian league cities that may lose their team have grown accustomed to having them around.  They’re in Virginia, West Virginia, North Carolina and Tennessee, far from any major league city. The Pioneer League even has long-standing teams in Billings and Great Falls, Montana, along with other teams in even more distant reaches.  If the teams go, the fans lose.  Potential broadcasters have fewer places to learn their craft.  ESPN broadcaster ++++Matt Vasgersian broke in as a rookie radio man in 1991 with the Appalachian League Huntington Cubs the same year I broke in with the Miracle.  You would think more_ minor league teams would be needed if MLB plans to expand.   As of now, that’s not the route MLB wishes to take.          

  • Chris Gallo
    October 21, 2019

    Of course the little guys will be hurt the most…it’s the way the big guys with the money usually work. Not only will job opportunities be lost but the development of baseball fans in remote corners of America will be stymied.
    I am really bothered by the possibility that this could or will happen.
    We lost our local independent league team here in Bridgeport CT when the mayor refused to renew a stadium lease in order to convert a local gem of a ballpark into an outdoor concert venue for 20 nights a year, while a 10,000 seat arena next door goes dark 200+ nights a year. A really stupid waste of money. It was another example of our national pastime not being shown the respect it deserves.

  • don wardlow
    October 21, 2019

    Chris, what happened to Bridgeport just isn’t right. Worse yet, I had forgotten there was a team in Bridgeport.

  • Troy Larson
    October 21, 2019

    There may also be a possobility that some Independent league teams becoming Minor League Affiliates. One such scenario would be the St. Paul Saints who are an independent league team. The Saints have not said that this would happen, but there is speculation that this could be the case given the fact the Saints currently play at CHS field which opened in 2016.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *